Puny Parker and mild-mannered Clark Kent

Today’s post- the first for some time-returns to my reviews of the Treasuries and Tabloids published by Marvel and DC in the Seventies.The Superman/Spider-Man team-up is another late addition to my collection: an online purchase from a year or so ago. Yet again, this was not a comic that I ever saw for sale anywhere in Lanarkshire in 1976.

supes spidey tabloid

It’s easy nowadays to forget how groundbreaking this inter-company crossover was. Yes, there had been nods to the characters from the rival companies in the past, largely in the form of parody, whether that was Not Brand Ecch or Inferior Five– or even the more sophisticated playfulness of the Englehart/Wein/Conway Rutland Hallowe’en stories. But this was the first time that two of the most recognisable heroes from the Big Two actually met- and brawled, in true Marvel style.

The tabloid is promoted as the “Battle of the Century”, a “Duel of Titans”. The prologue features a clash between Superman and Luthor’s giant robot. It’s very redolent of the rather corny, childish milieu of Seventies Superman and  jock sports presenter Steve Lombard’s bucket of water prank is a groan-worthy scene. There’s also a cringe-making reference to “Truth, Justice and the Terran Way”. You can see why the Gothic horror and grotesque criminals of Gotham propelled Batman to the status of fandom’s darling.

The sequence that follows depicts Spidey taking down Doc Ock and his Flying Octopus. The campery of that gimmick aside, this is recognisably the Peter Parker of the Conway/Andru era- he’s even wearing the ghastly Xmas sweater I remember from the Jackal storyarc.  Conway’s JJJ- like a lot of Merry Gerry’s  high-status charcters -seems, alarmingly,  on the verge of a nervous breakdown.

Surprisingly, it takes nearly fifty pages before the duel of titans to  take place. The story then takes on a global scope: from Kilimanjaro to the long-unseen satellite of the JLA’s Injustice Gang. There’s a sly gag about seeing “too many Bond movies” as the Ock/Luthor team unleash a series of natural disasters from the orbiting Skylab- er, Comlab. Supey’s god-like Bronze Age Kryptonian powers avert a tsunami and the adventure ends with the suggestion that Parker has guessed Clark Kent’s secret.

Despite the melodramatic and corny story, the tabloid has great charm, scale and colour. It’s a perfect all-ages book: the camaraderie of the heroes (and the villains!) would be hard to imagine in a modern teaming of , say, Woverine and Batman (which would probably be a ten-issue “event” with multiple tie-ins).

Conway’s long tenures on JLA and the LSH weren’t favourites of mine during the late 70s-early 80s. I found his writing shrill and formulaic compared to Englehart, Claremont- even Wein. However now, in  middle age, I can appreciate his craftsmanship more. This is an entertaining popcorn comic with a timeless quality that makes it suitable for a wide audience, even for modern kids.

Coming soon : Jack and Stan (Kubrick, that is) 

All images are presumed copyright of their respective owners




One comment on “Puny Parker and mild-mannered Clark Kent

  1. Kid Robson says:

    I know it was available in Glasgow, because I asked a friend to pick one up for me on the way back from his work in the Town. (Why do we say we’re going into Town when we mean the City? H’mm.) I was ill in bed, but I couldn’t wait for his knock on my door so that I could get my grubby hands on it. I felt it was very cinematic, both in the way it looked and was constructed – it would probably still make a good movie. I’ve got two originals of this Treasury Edition, plus at least two reprints of it. Where did the 37 years go, eh?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s